Die voorspelling van gevaarlikheid: 'n psigoforensiese studie
Loading...
Files
Date
Authors
Strydom, Christoffel Cornelius
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
University of the Free State
Abstract
Showing abstract in English
English: The prediction of dangerousness, more recently known as risk management, has become
an integral part of the criminal justice system. The purpose of these predictions is to make
an significant contribution in the prevention of violent crime. Although predictions of this
nature as well as research on this fenomenon have been around on the international
scene for more than two decades, almost nothing has been done in this regard in South
Africa. This is especially distressing because of the current violent crime rate in this
country and specifically because of the detrimental effect it has on the victims and their
families, the community at large and the country as a whole politically, financially and
mental healthwise. Significant reduction of violent crime, also through effective
predictions, should be seen as a national priority
The main purpose of this study was to alleviate the apparent lack of research in South-
Africa on the prediction of dangerousness; more specifically, to identify the criteria which
the involved professionals (i.e. magistrates and psychologists), use when determining
dangerousness. A secondary purpose was to test the respondents on several related
matters (eg. prejudice, training and the most effective sentencing) when sentencing of
violent crime is considered. The perceptions of the involved role players were obtained
through a self compiled questionnaire. Answers to specific questions concerning
dangerousness and related forensic aspects, and evaluating of fictional case studies,
were where applicable, amplified by qualitative comment.
The core findings were the following:
- the most important violence predicting criteria identified by both respondent-groups,
were: repeated exposure to violence, a history of violent conduct, threats to commit
violence and (to a limited extent), a history of treatment of certain psychiatric disorders;
- the occupational groups differed in the emphasis that was placed on certain risk factors
(eg. psychologists accentuated factors like age, sex, absence of violent history and
remorse, more than the lawyer-group did); and
- the views of the psychologists on psycho-forensic aspects relating to sentencing of
violent offenders, were more supported by empirical research, than the opinions of the
magistrates.
It is specifically recommended that research on the effective prediction of violent
behaviour be done on an ongoing basis and that it should receive national priority and
funding.