Towards the development of a sustainable management strategy for Canis mesomelas and caracal on rangeland
Abstract
English: South Africa has a long history of human-wildlife conflict with black-backed jackal Canis mesomelas and caracal Caracal caracal, especially in the small livestock industry. Recently, wildlife ranchers and cattle farmers have also started to report losses. Despite the excessive losses and widespread efforts to curb these conflicts there is no sustainable human predator conflict management (HPCM) strategy in place. Livestock owners still tackle the challenges individually or in small groups and concentrate mostly on elimination and precautionary techniques. Blanket-control and poisoning practices in many areas results in biodiversity being under constant threat, while stock losses do not decline. Current knowledge on aspects relating to black-backed jackal and caracal in South Africa (including ecology, economics, management techniques, predation rates, sociology) was collated and evaluated. Such information is needed for the development of a sustainable HPCM strategy for damage-causing black-backed jackal and caracal on livestock farms and wildlife ranches, and to inform policy and decision-making related to these species. There is a general lack of scientific information on virtually all the identified aspects, limiting the development of management strategies. Specific information gaps with regards to each aspect were identified and a conceptual model presented for the development of a sustainable HPCM plan for damage-causing black-backed jackal and caracal in South African rangeland. Most of the available ecological research on black-backed jackal and caracal are from spatially and temporally isolated studies, limited in scope, confined to protected areas and not focused on the development of sustainable management strategies. This results in a limited understanding of the ecological role of both black-backed jackal and caracal in South African ecosystems. A prerequisite for sustainable HPCM programs is a sound ecological understanding of the animals that are to be managed, and the ecosystems in which they operate. Without such an understanding it is difficult to predict the contribution of different management v interventions to mitigate damage and the effects on the behaviour and ecology of target animals. The study has also highlighted the overall lack of scientific estimations on the economics of black-backed jackal and caracal predation, and HPCM operations. Isolated pieces of evidence confirm that the current associated costs are high. A range of benefits and costs associated with these two species, which have not yet been quantified, are also emphasized. With reference to the human dimension there is insufficient information to understand the diversity of perceptions which various stakeholders may hold towards black-backed jackal, caracal and associated HPCM actions. Understanding these perceptions and its drivers are most important for the drafting of a sustainable HPCM strategy. Further, scientific information on HPCM methods for black-backed jackal and caracal in South Africa is lacking. Most information on these methods is contained in popular literature and very few refer specifically to the management of damage-causing black-backed jackal or caracal. A number of information gaps have been identified regarding the effectiveness of available HPCM methods to curb black-backed jackal and caracal predation under different South African conditions. Some major shortcomings have been identified in the availability of current predation information. The small number of available sources on livestock and wildlife predation is limiting an understanding of specifically black-backed jackal or caracal predation patterns. Better qualitative information on livestock and wildlife predation is needed to substantiate reported losses, and provide grounds for HPCM decisions. Moreover, it could also be used to better understand the dynamics of the predation which is necessary to develop sustainable HPCM strategies. Future research should be directed, coordinated and conducted systematically to ensure that the understanding of these damage-causing species is complemented and priority knowledge gaps filled in a focused way. Setting short and long-term goals is important, as well as the continuous feedback between participating scientists, livestock farmers, wildlife ranchers, conservation managers, legislation officials, the coordinator(s) and the public. Afrikaans: Suid-Afrika het ‘n lang geskiedenis van konflik tussen mense en die rooijakkals
Canis mesomelas en rooikat Caracal caracal. Alhoewel die meeste konflik in die
verlede in die kleinvee industrie paasgevind het, is daar meer onglangs ook
bewerings van bees- en wildboere dat hulle verliese as gevolg van hierdie twee
predatore ervaar. Nieteenstaande die bomatige verliese en weidverspreide pogings
om hierdie konflik te stop is daar geen volhoubare bestuurs strategie in plek. Vee
eienaars probeer tans die probleem op hulle eie of in klein groepe oplos en daarvoor
maak hulle meestal gebruik van metodes wat predator getalle uitdun en predasie
voorkom. Oorhoofse beheer en gif word in baie areas gebruik. Hierdie metodes is
egter selde suksesvol om veeverliese te verminder en in baie gevalle plaas dit net
ekstra druk op die biodiversiteit in hierdie areas.
Huidige kennis oor aspekte rakende die rooijakkals en die rooikat in Suid-Afrika
(insluitende ekologie, ekonomie, bestuurs metodes, predasie getalle, sosiologie) is
saamgevoeg en krities ondersoek. Hierdie inligting is nodig vir die opstel van ‘n
volhoubare strategie vir die bestuur van die skade veroorsaakende rooijakkals en
rooikat op vee- en wildsplase en om beleidvorming en besluitneming rakende hierdie
twee spesies in te lig.
Daar is ‘n algemene tekortkoming van wetenskaplike inligting oor feitlik al die
geïdentifiseerde aspekte wat die ontwikkeling van suksesvolle bestuurs strategieë
belemmer. Spesifieke inligtings tekorte ten opsigte van elke aspek is geïdentifiseer
en ‘n konsep model word hiervolgens voorgestel van wat nodig is vir die ontwikkeling
van ‘n volhoubare bestuurs plan vir skade veroorsakende rooijakkals en rooikat op
vee- en wildsplase in Suid Afrika.
Meeste van die ekologiese navorsing op beide die rooijakkals en rooikat is van
geïsoleerde areas, is gedoen oor ‘n kort tydperk, het ‘n beperkte omvang, is meestal
in natuurreservate uitgevoer en het nie gefokus op die ontwikkeling van volhoubare
bestuurs strategieë nie. Die inligting dra ook net by tot ‘n beperkte kennis oor die
ekologiese rol van rooijakkals en rooikat in Suid Afrikaanse ekosisteme. ‘n
Volhoubare bestuurs strategieë is gegrond op ‘n ferm ekologiese kennis oor die diere wat bestuur word, asook oor die ekosisteme waarin hulle voorkom. Sonder
hierdie kennis is dit moeilik om te voorspel watter toevoeging verskillende bestuurs
ingrypings kan maak om skade te verminder en watter effek dit kan hê op die gedrag
en ekologie van die teiken diere.
Die studie het ook die algemene tekort van wetenskaplike skattings oor die
ekonomiese waarde van rooijakkals en rooikat predasie, asook die bestuurs
praktyke wat teen hulle gebruik word, uitgewys. Geïsoleerde studies dui daarop dat
die huidige kostes geassosieer met rooijakkals en rooikat hoog kan wees. Verder
word ander moontlike kostes en voordele wat ook met hierdie twee spesies
geassosieer kan word, maar wat nog nie bepaal is nie, ook uitgewys. Met verwysing
tot die menslike aspek is daar ook baie beperkte inligting om die verskillende
persepsies wat belangehebbendes oor die rooijakkals en rooikat en die bestuur van
hierdie spesies mag hê te kan verstaan. Dit is belangrik om hierdie persepsies asook
die faktore wat hierdie persepsies beinvloed te verstaan voordat ‘n volhoubare
bestuurs strategie opgestel kan word.
Daar is verder ook ‘n tekort van inligting oor bestuur metodes wat gebruik kan word
teen die rooijakkals en rooikat. Meeste van die inligting wat beskikbaar is, is in
populêre publikasies opgeskryf terwyl net ‘n paar van die bronne spesifiek verwys na
die bestuur van die rooijakkals en rooikat. Verskeie inligtings tekorte is geïdentifiseer
rakende die effektiwiteit van moontlike metodes wat gebruik kan word om rooijakkals
en rooikat skade te beheer onder Suid Afrikaanse toestande.
Verskeie terkortkominge is uitgewys rakende die beskikbaarheid en aard van
predasie inligting. Die klein bietjie inligting is onvoldoende om spesifiek rooijakkalse
en rooikatte se predasiepatrone te verstaan. Beter kwalitatiewe inligting oor predasie
op vee en wild word benodig om beweerde skade toegesryf aan predasie te bevestig
en om bewys te lewer vir moontlike bestuurs besluite rakende hierdie predasies.
Hierdie inligting kan verder ook gebruik word om die dinamika van predasie te
verstaan. Laasgenoemde is belangrik vir die ontwikkeling van volhoubare bestuurs
strategieë gemik op skade veroorsakende predatore. Dit word voorgestel dat toekomstige navorsing op die rooijakkals en rooikat
sistematies uitgevoer moet word op ‘n gekoördineerde wyse om te verseker dat ons
kennis van hierdie spesies uitgebou word en prioritiet areas waar inligting kort
aangespreek word. Dit is ook belangrik om kort- en langtermyn mikpunte daar te stel
en dat daar volgehoue terugvoer plaasvind tussen deelnemende weteskaplikes, veeen
wildboere, bewarings beamptes, wetstoepassers, die koördineerders van
predator bestuur en die publiek.
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
A managerial perspective on factors leading to failure in information technology projects
Ghebre-egziabiher, Tesfagabir Ghebreyohannes (University of the Free State, 2005-11)English: This research is based on data collected between April and May 2004 from 150 sample companies registered at the Johannesburg Stock Exchange. The study was organised into six chapters. The first chapter presents ... -
A management model for a pharmaceutical contract research organization
Jacobs, Yvonne Leonie (University of the Free State, 2004-05)English: Competitive success for a Contract Research Organization (CRO) entails unlimited process improvement to sustain excellence. Chapter One describes the generic business environment CROs operated in which customers ... -
'n Projekbestuurdersprofiel vir die konstruksiebedryf
Archer, Mart-Mari (University of the Free State, 2011)English: Project managers within the construction industry possibly have a lack of sufficient and effective management skills. This study aims to find solutions, and to propose a model with guidelines for creating a profile ...